" Eli Manning 's birth certificate says he will always be Peyton's little brother, but at least now all the condescending comparisons and questions have finally stopped.

Eli won a Super Bowl in his fourth season with the Giants , less than half the time it took Peyton to win his Super Bowl with the Colts , which came in his ninth season. Peyton was named Super Bowl MVP. Twelve months later, Eli took home the same trophy.

If you had to choose, there's no doubt Peyton is still the better player. But since quarterbacks are ultimately judged by their Super Bowl rings, the score is 1-1.

"I think Eli did more to win the Super Bowl than his brother," said one GM, referring to the entire playoff run. "He did more for the Giants than Peyton did for the Colts given all the adversity that the Giants had to go through to get there. It was a cakewalk for the Colts. I don't think you could say enough about what Eli did." "